New York’s S8877 would fine employers and job platforms whose postings lack a timeframe for filling the role: $2,500 per noncompliant print ad or digital post, rising to $5,000 if uncorrected within 30 days and doubling for every subsequent 30 days. Employers must also remove a posting within two weeks of filling the role, and third parties have two weeks from learning a role is filled. It joins Pennsylvania’s HB2321 and a New Jersey bill, S2136, in a widening multi-state wave.
Why it matters to the HR leader: ghost jobs are moving from a reputational annoyance to a line-item liability. A job board that auto-copies postings, or a recruiter who leaves a filled requisition live to “keep a pipeline warm,” now creates compounding statutory penalties, not just candidate frustration. A 2025 Congressional Research Service report noted companies post phantom roles to evaluate talent pools, signal to staff that they are replaceable, or suggest growth to investors.
The signal underneath: regulators are treating job postings as labor-market data, not marketing. A MyPerfectResume analysis found nearly one in three U.S. listings never result in a hire, a “ghost job economy” that wastes seekers’ time and distorts the openings figures policymakers rely on. Hiring transparency is becoming its own compliance domain with an audit trail, much as pay transparency did, and Pennsylvania’s bill would even require disclosing how far AI is used in hiring. HR leaders should enforce posting-expiry and fill-timeline rules now, across direct and third-party channels, rather than after the first multi-state penalty.
Source: HR Dive.
Related on this site: Workforce Analytics Vendors Promise to Replace HR Dashboards With Predictive Models.
